Sun 12 Aug 2007
direct action! banner drop on great wall of china for a free tibet
Posted by anjali under culture , intl trade & econ , nonviolent resistance , press this , state-sponsored violence , technology for the masses[7] Comments
A few days ago, on the eve of the 1 year anniversary of the Olympics (that China’s hosting), a group of activists performed a HUGE banner drop of a Free Tibet banner ON the Great wall of China! My friend Nupur Modi participated in it, and there are videos and other links on the Students for a Free Tibet website. Lhadon Tethong, the executive Director of Students for a Free Tibet was also in China blogging about her experiences there (which I hear is illegal to do in China) during and after the event. She runs a text and video blog at Beijing Wide Open, it’s phenomenal (and she’s hot too). :>
They were all detained after the event, by Chinese authorities, but now are safe and home in the US and Canada. Lhadon writes:
I know we did this and got off pretty easy. And while I appreciate that some people think I did something brave, I’m not sure I did. Bravery is standing in front of a tank in Tiananmen Square. Bravery is getting on a stage in Tibet and calling for the return of the Dalai Lama. Bravery is going to Beijing to petition to get compensation for your confiscated farmland to the very same government that probably took it in the first place. All this, with no protection. No foreign passport, government, or official body that will defend you.
What I did, what we did, it was nothing in comparison. But I hope and I pray that somehow we have made a difference in the battle for human rights and freedom in Tibet and in China. The Olympics spotlight is on the Chinese leadership now and they want the world to believe they are open and free. But they are not. They demonstrated this by deporting me at the very moment that the one-year countdown to the Beijing 2008 Olympic Games was taking place in Tiananmen square. Paul and I just wanted to attend. To see it for ourselves and to blog about it like one should be able to in any place that truly enjoys freedom.
Some people have said we got what we deserved. Others have suggested we got off to lightly and should act more responsibly next time. I think it is the regime in Beijing – unelected, unaccountable and tyrannical – that should act more responsibly. I think our government, governments around the world, corporations doing business in China and the IOC itself, should act more responsibly. They are the ones who have clear and direct influence over Beijing. They are the ones who could make a huge impact by doing just a little in the way of speaking up for and promoting human rights and democracy.
Until this happens, we will keep doing what we have to do – challenging China’s control over Tibet and working to make the occupation too costly to maintain. One thing is clear in all this Olympics mess, the Chinese government cares what the world thinks. If they didn’t, they wouldn’t spend so much time trying to get us all to like them with slogans like “One World One Dream.” Knowing this, we must push them to change. And if our direct actions are seen as stunts by a few, I trust the vast majority will see them for what they really are, nonviolent expressions of dissent and protest to bring positive social and political change to people living under brutal oppression.
For Tibetans, Uighurs, Southern Mongolians, Taiwanese, Falun Gong, Christians, Catholics, farmers, factory workers, lawyers, doctors, journalists and every other person who lives under fear of persecution by the Chinese Communist Party and their goons, I say, we will never give up.
We stand with you.
Definitely check out her blog Beijing Wide Open. She’s inspired a little part of me to start videoblogging. But not yet, i’ve gotta marinate on it a bit.
My friend Nupur Modi, who was one of 6 who actually performed the banner drop, writes this:
We had the glamorous jobs. We were the ones to hang a banner on the Great Wall and make sure the footage got out to the world. I’m not saying that doing the action, and then being detained in China, being interrogated, and facing extreme consequences wasn’t hard and challenging.
But the hardest part is the unknown. And you all had to face the most of that. We were dealing with the situation minute-by-minute in bite-sized pieces. But not knowing what was happening to people you care about and not hearing from them for days, that can be distressing.
I truly appreciate all of your amazing strength, support, thoughts, and prayers through the process.
While we were in police custody trying to find the most comfortable position to sleep and pass the time in old Chinese police station chairs (answer: there is none), we found comfort and strength knowing that folks on the outside were working nonstop: getting media and the word out, pulling strings via diplomatic channels, calling and pressuring the embassies, providing emotional support to friends and family, etc., etc., etc. The six of us weren’t the only ones in that action, it was a whole community effort. I probably will never know about all the people who were involved and all the crucial roles they played, but I owe you all a sincere THANK YOU.
I truly appreciate all of emails and phone calls of commendation for my courage and “bad-ass-ness”. But let us please not forget the issue at hand. I am a US citizen, and with it comes innumerable benefits, resources, and privileges. I had it easy. Tibetans are struggling and taking action every single day, facing constant repression and violent rule. They don’t have freedom of speech or religion, and they are trying to preserve their culture. They are the true heroes.
Thank you, thank you, Nupur and the rest who participated in this action.
Oh I also wanted to add this — check out an interview on Canadian TV with Lhadon — what’s the most phenomenal, i think, is the amount of airtime they devote to this human rights issue. Would you EVER see this much time devoted to Tibet in the US? We’ve gotta break down the mainstream media, it’s brainwashing us all.
Think about supporting Students for a Free Tibet in whatever way you can. Whether that’s being the media (spread the word) or otherwise…



August 12th, 2007 at 9:36 pm
Why don’t we righteous Americans/Canadians set a good example for the Chinese by reliniquishing our established statehood towards Native American Independence? First Nation Independence?
Of cours not, we are hypocrits. We want to keep our stolen land and demand Tibet Independence.
Proverb says “people living in glass house should not throw stones.”
Not sure if esteemed LA is aware of the fact Students for a free Tibet is conntected with the Canadian government thru PM Harper’s advisor Tenzin Khangsar:
http://www.google.com/search?q=Tenzin+Khangsar+Students+For+Free+Tibet
August 13th, 2007 at 10:38 pm
Thanks for your comment, Charles. I hear you on the stolen land, yes to a degree ALL americans are hypocrites. But I’m not going to stop thinking about other colonial and destructive endeavors by other states just because the U.S. participates in colonial and destructive endeavors.
I take to heart your reminder about our stolen land. I care passionately about native americans’ rights and try to keep up also on what struggles of theirs I can participate in. I would love for them to be able to reclaim their land. I also hope to work in the Indian Health Service in the future, serving in teh role of the physician, and help to heal…
August 14th, 2007 at 12:29 pm
“love for them to be able to reclaim their land” translates to – NO INDEPENDENCE FOR YOU!!!
(I hope you are a big Seinfeld fan like me 8-)
That’s not the same is it? If we don’t have the heart to measure ourselves, what right do we have to demand others?
Proverv also says “charity begins at home”.
BTW why ain’t the Chinese sending Students for a Free Native America here to hang flag and contraven our laws? SFT’s connection with the Canadian government is cited above.
My guess is the Chinese don’t have the kind of hatred and animosesy we have for them.
August 16th, 2007 at 5:46 pm
Charles Liu has been awfully busy… I keep seeing his comments on story after story concerning the recent Students for a Free Tibet (SFT) protest. So to respond finally: First, Tibetans who make up a lot of the leadership of SFT have their own fight. And I personally know of non-Tibetan SFT activists who in addition to supporting Tibet, also campaign for justice for native/First Nations people in the U.S. and Canada. But handing the countries back to its’ native human population by removing 335 million invaders isn’t a possibility. Non-Tibetans supporting the Tibetan struggle isn’t hypocrisy, it’s solidarity and learning from history. And finally, on the rumor-mongering about Tenzin Khangsar, you just have the wrong guy. The one who is connected to the conservatives in Canada is a guy in his mid-30s who is NOT a member of SFT. The one who is a member is a 22-year old recent college grad. Yes, they have the same (quite common) name. Google it yourself again – it’s easy enough to figure out.
August 17th, 2007 at 10:41 am
“campaign for justice for native/First Nations people in the U.S. and Canada” is not “independence” is it?
If we are not willing to give our own “Tibet” independence, what right do we have to demand the Chinese?
Why not ask for “justice for Tibetans in China”? Sounds like self-righteous hypocrisy to me.
And I am no where near “busy” as y’all are – I ain’t the one taking directions (and money?) from people like Ten
August 17th, 2007 at 10:44 am
zin Khangsar and booking all they way to China.
And who are you trying to kid, Tenzin Khangsar was part of SFT and Tibet independence leadership in Canada before he hooked up with Harper:
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/elections/fed2005/candidates/generated/24011_CON.html
September 9th, 2007 at 12:37 am
Sorry Charles but if you’re trying to convince people that SFT is a shadow organization secretly run by conservatives in Canada, you’re just going to end up getting laughed at. SFT’s values and modus operandi are about as unconservative as you can get, which you’d see right away if you took any time to research the organization and its programs of leadership building, which are much larger and in many ways more important than the glamorous protests you see in the news.
As for why not campaign for “Justice for Tibetans in China”.. The vast majority of Tibetans (save for a few in Beijing, Chengdu, etc.) are not in China. Tibet is Tibet, not China, and it will always be Tibet. Invading someone else’s country does not make it yours, no matter how much you lie, bribe, and strongarm other governments into believing it. Speaking of which, what do you have to say for this:
http://www.phayul.com/news/article.aspx?id=17860
You should be thoroughly ashamed of your beloved motherland!